In his March 1999 Educational Leadership article, “Why Standardized Tests Don’t Measure Education Quality,” James Popham observed, “Asserting that low test scores are caused by the quality of education is illogical.” Popham identifies three things that influence test scores: what is taught in school, a student’s native
- 1 Why standardized tests do not measure educational quality?
- 2 Do standardized tests measure educational quality?
- 3 How standardized tests do not effectively measure student achievement?
- 4 Why standardized tests aren’t working for teachers or students?
- 5 What are the disadvantages of standardized testing?
- 6 Do standardized tests improve education or have the opposite effect?
- 7 How does standardized testing affect teaching quality?
Why standardized tests do not measure educational quality?
The overarching reason that students’ scores on these tests do not provide an accurate index of educational effectiveness is that any inference about educational quality made on the basis of students’ standardized achievement test performances is apt to be invalid.
Do standardized tests measure educational quality?
So, do standardized tests measure educational quality? Yes, they do. Standardized tests should be just one of many measures that are used to evaluate students’ abilities and their readiness for college or a career.
How standardized tests do not effectively measure student achievement?
Studies indicate that standardized tests reward superficial thinking and may discourage more analytical thinking. Additionally, because of the small sample of knowledge that is tested, standardized tests provide a very incomplete picture of student achievement.
Why standardized tests aren’t working for teachers or students?
A lot of classroom time is dedicated to preparing for these tests and giving them. Results are affected by dozens of variables that we can’t control: illness, hunger, sleep deprivation, unfamiliar forms of a test, limited command of English.
What are the disadvantages of standardized testing?
List of the Disadvantages of Standardized Testing
- It promises big results that do not usually happen.
- It can be very expensive for some states.
- It is not always a true reflection of a student’s knowledge.
- It assumes all students come from a similar learning background.
Do standardized tests improve education or have the opposite effect?
Standardized tests negatively impact education Yet, studies have shown that students are more successful when focused on learning rather than on exam performance.
How does standardized testing affect teaching quality?
Standardized tests measure achievement against goals rather than measuring progress. Achievement test scores are commonly assumed to have a strong correlation with teaching effectiveness, a tendency that can place unfair blame on good teachers if scores are low and obscure teaching deficiencies if scores are high.